report:soa

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision		 Previous revision
report:soa [2026/04/12 11:18] – [Key Technologies] team1report:soa [2026/04/21 14:05] (current) – [Aerogarden harvest] team1
Line 1: Line 1:
 ===== 2. Background and Related Work ===== ===== 2. Background and Related Work =====
-//This chapter provides the reader with the relevant technical-scientific background as well as existing related products and research, also known as the state of the art, in the field(s) of the project.// 
  
 ==== Introduction ==== ==== Introduction ====
-//Provide here an overview of the contents (structure) of this chapter.// 
-==== Geoponics and hydroponics ==== 
-Determining the most efficient method for indoor herb cultivation is necessary to first understand how growth environments affect plant development. In the context of Screen to Green, the medium must act as a responsive bio-indicator of a user’s digital habits while remaining clean and practical for a modern desk environment. 
  
-Traditionally, plants are grown in soil (geoponics), where organic matter acts as a reservoir for water and nutrients. However, soil is often unsuitable for desk-side IoT devices due to its bulk, the potential for mess, and its tendency to harbor pests like fungus gnats [(Barbosa)]. Crucially, soil’s high moisture retention creates a "buffer" that delays visible wilting. For our project, this is a major disadvantage, as we need the plant to show relatively quick visual feedback when a user exceeds their screen time limit. 
  
-An alternative is Hydroponics, specifically Deep Water Culture (DWC). This method suspends roots directly in an oxygenated, nutrient-rich water solution. While DWC is very efficient and clean, it can be technically demanding to maintain in a small, portable pot. This led our team to research a "middle ground" known as Semi-Hydroponics using inorganic mineral substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis.+The following chapter presents the scientific and technical background relevant to the project, as well as an overview of existing solutions. It begins with describing the relationship between smartphone usage and mental health, highlighting the negative effects of excessive screen time and the need for innovative approaches to support healthier digital behavior. 
 +Moreover, current digital solutions are analyzed, with a focus on their design principles, functionality and limitations. The chapter then outlines the physical domain by introducing hydroponics, plant cultivation methods and smart farming technologies, which form the foundation for integrating biological systems into the project. 
 +Finally, existing products and systems are compared in order to identify gaps and opportunities. This analysis helps justify the design direction of Screen2Green and establishes the basis for the following chapters.
  
-Lechuza Pon and Seramis are specialized growing media made of stones like pumice, zeolites, and volcanic rock, or baked clay granules. Unlike soil, these "grains" are sterile, meaning they don't have worms or attract bugs. They act like a sponge: they soak up the exact amount of water the plant needs and leave plenty of space for air, which prevents root rot.+==== Smartphone Usage and Mental Health ====
  
-The general advantages of these soilless and mineral systems include:+The rapid increase in smartphone usage has raised significant concerns regarding its impact on mental health, particularly among young people and students. Numerous studies have found a consistent association between excessive screen time and negative psychological outcomes such as anxiety, depression and stress. 
 +For example, a study on university students found that as daily screen time increased, levels of anxiety and depression also increased significantly. In particular, screen use above approximately 6.5 hours per day was associated with a higher risk of mental health problems [(zhang2025)]. 
 +Several mechanisms help explain the relationship between smartphone use and mental health. One important factor is sleep disruption. Screen exposure, particularly before bedtime, can interfere with sleep quality, which is strongly associated with increased stress and emotional instability.
  
-Controlled Nutrition: Nutrients are delivered directly to the roots in a water-soluble form for faster absorption [(resh2022)].+Another important aspect is the addictive nature of smartphone use, particularly in relation to social media. Studies have shown that compulsive smartphone use is associated with higher levels of psychological distress, including anxiety and depression [(rozgonjuk2018)]. This is often explained by reward mechanisms in apps, such as notifications and social feedback, which reinforce habitual checking behavior and make it difficult for users to regulate their screen time.
  
-Cleanliness: Removing organic soil eliminates dirt spills and indoor pests, which is a priority for a student's workspace [(Barbosa)].+Importantly, research also suggests that reducing smartphone usage can lead to measurable improvements in mental health. A randomized controlled trial demonstrated that lowering screen time resulted in improved well-being and reduced psychological distress among participants [(pieh2025)].
  
-Water Efficiency: These systems use much less water than soil because the moisture is held within the inorganic grains or a small reservoir rather than evaporating into the dirt [(alshrouf2017hydroponics)].+Overall, existing research indicates a clear relationship between excessive smartphone use and negative mental health outcomes. While smartphones offer many benefits, their overuse can contribute to stress, anxiety, depression, and reduced well-being. These findings underline the importance of developing tools and systems that help users manage their screen time more effectively.
  
-Visual Responsiveness: Because these substrates don't have the heavy "water-holding" mass of thick soil, they allow the basil to react more quickly to our automated watering schedule.+==== Existing Digital Solutions ====
  
-While pure DWC is an excellent scientific tool, the use of inorganic substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis offers a slight advantage for Screen to Green. They provide the "grainy" look of soil that users are familiar with, but with the high-tech, clean, and responsive benefits of a hydroponic system and the water reservoir can be smaller than in DWC system. +The increasing use of smartphones has raised concerns about distraction, reduced productivity and digital addiction [(elhai2017)]. In response, many mobile applications have been developed to help users reduce screen time and improve focus. These applications typically rely on behavioural design strategies such as gamification, timers and reward systems to encourage users to stay away from their phones [(duke2017)]. One of the most widely known examples is the mobile application Forest, which has popularized the concept of visualizing focus time through the growth of virtual plants.
-==== Comparative Growth Analysis: The Case of Basil ==== +
-To make our Screen to Green project work, we really needed to look at how specific plants behave in different environments, and basil turned out to be the perfect choice for our "biological mirror." We found a very important study by Saha et al. [(Saha2016)] that focused exactly on what we are trying to do: comparing common basil grown in traditional soil versus soilless environments. Basil is a great herb for this project because it is very visually-responsive, meaning you can actually see it change based on how much water it has. In the study, the researchers showed that basil in a soilless setup grows much faster and looks much healthier than basil growing in regular dirt. While some systems use only water, our research also points toward "semi-hydroponic" methods using inorganic substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis. These are essentially clean, sterile grains that act like a high-tech version of soil without the mess or the bugs. This is really important for our goal of helping people with phone addiction because we want the user to see a "reward" for their hard work. If person is not exceeding their screen time limits or a student is staying focused and studying without their phone, a soilless system allows the basil to grow big and green very quickly. However, because these inorganic substrates and water-based systems don't have the heavy "buffer" of organic dirt, the plant becomes more sensitive to our watering schedule. This is actually a huge benefit for our project; it means that if a user spends too much time scrolling and our system stops the optimal watering, the basil will start to droop and wilt much faster than it would in thick soil. This creates a quick and clear "physical warning" that tells the user to put their phone down and get back to real life. +
-The following are the key scientific findings based on this research: +
-  * Faster Growth Height: The researchers found that basil in soilless systems grew taller than the soil-grown plants in the same amount of time. This helps our users see the results of their good study habits almost immediately [(Saha2016)]. +
-  * More Leaves to See: The study showed that these plants have a much higher leaf count and a bigger total leaf area. This makes the plant look "extra lush," which is the exact visual reward we want to give our users for staying off their phones [(Saha2016)]. +
-  * Better Root Development: Because the roots in water or loose grains like Seramis don't have to push through hard, compacted dirt, they grow longer and more efficiently. This makes the plant more sensitive to the water levels we control with our system [(Saha2016)]. +
-  * Lower Water Waste: Even though it seems like it uses a lot of water, soilless methods actually save water compared to soil because the moisture is targeted at the roots and doesn't just evaporate into the dirt [(Saha2016)]. +
-  * Cleanliness for Apartments: Unlike soil, which was found to be messy and can attract bugs like gnats, using inorganic grains or water stays clean and sterile, which is much better for a student's desk [(Barbosa)].+
  
-==== Concepts ==== 
  
-  * Herb growth +=== Applications ===
-  * Vertical Gardening +
-  * Screen time & its impact on mental health +
-  * Growing plants & how it improves mental health +
-  * How artificial light improves plant growth +
-  * Aroma therapy+
  
-=== Growing herbs === +== Forest == 
-Herbs are plants commonly used in cooking due to their distinctive aromas and flavors. Examples include basil, thyme, oregano, rosemary, and cilantro. These plants can be cultivated in soil or through hydroponic systems. Propagation is possible either from seeds or from cuttings, with cuttings generally providing faster results.+The application Forest represents one of the most successful examples of this concept. The app was released in 2016 and is available on both mobile platforms and web browsers. Forest encourages users motivation and productivity by using a simulated forest that's maintained by the user. With every productive session, the user grows a virtual tree and when that tree is fully grown, the user starts growing another one. With this, the user is growing a virtual forest, taking care of it by studying, working or being off the phone in general. 
  
-The cultivation process begins with either sowing seeds or preparing cuttings. Seed sowing involves placing seeds in a nutrient-rich environment suitable for germination. This environment must provide optimal levels of water, oxygen, and temperature. Seeds may be sown in nutrient-rich soil or in hydroponic systems, often within smaller, controlled environments that allow for easy transplantation after germination. Certain seeds, such as those of licorice or lemon balm, require scarification—a process in which the seed coat is slightly nicked to facilitate nutrient absorption.+When the user stops the session midway, the current tree dies and the user's forest doesn't grow, countering the user's tendency to open social media during their focus session. Alternatively, when the user enters a focus session, all notifications are blocked, minimizing the user's tendency to get distracted by notifications.
  
-An alternative propagation method involves the use of cuttings. In this approach, a stem is removed from an existing herb plant and placed directly into a growing environment. This method accelerates growth since the cutting already has an established structure. Over time, roots develop, and the stem becomes a fully independent plant. This process can be repeated by taking additional cuttings from the newly grown plant. Even commercially purchased herbs can serve as viable sources for cuttings, making this method particularly advantageous for hydroponic systems.+== Liven == 
 +This app focuses on countering dopamine deficit and procrastination by creating a personal guide with the user during app usage. Liven uses a balance of teaching, self exploration, experience. The user gets taught on dopamine, procrastination and stress-related topics. Inbetween lessons, the app asks the user questions in order to understand the user better, leading to more personalized guidance. While using the app, the user can log their personal thoughts and feelings, which in turn lead to generated affirmation phrases and even more personalized guidance. Lastly, the user receives exercises regarding mental and physical health.
  
-Successful growth requires adequate sunlight to enable photosynthesis, allowing the plant to produce compounds necessary for development. Most herbs require approximately 6 to 8 hours of sunlight per day, although light intensity requirements vary between species [(Jill MacKenzie and Shirley Mah Kooyman, University of Minnesota, 2021. https://extension.umn.edu/vegetables/growing-herbs [Accessed in March 2026].)]. For example, basil typically requires more intense sunlight than bay leaves. In addition to light, proper airflow, temperature, and humidity levels are essential. Adequate airflow helps prevent fungal growth, while optimal temperatures generally range between 18°C and 24°C. In hydroponic systems, maintaining the correct pH level is also critical, with most herbs thriving in a range between 5.5 and 6.5.+Liven focuses on personalizing the journey to improve, leading to every user having a unique journey fitting their needs and personality. Using animations that are soft to the eyes, phrases throughout the user's journey for affirmation and the option to personally log thoughts and feelings, Liven allows users to guide themselves to learn about their flaws and how to work with them.
  
-These environmental factors remain important throughout the maintenance phase. Poor regulation of these conditions can lead to plant diseases, often indicated by discoloration. Common issues include downy mildew and, in the case of mint, mint rust. Infected plants can often be treated by removing affected leaves to prevent further spread.+== Minimalist Phone == 
 +This app minimizes distractions by turning the phone into a screen with a timer and no apps. The user downloads the Minimalist Phone launcher app in their preferred application store. Using the launcher, the user locks away all forms of distraction including notifications, access to apps and even overwhelming colors such as the user's wallpaper. 
  
-Under optimal conditions, most herbs reach a harvestable stage within 6 to 8 weeks. However, plants grown from cuttings may require only half that time. Growth rates vary among species, with herbs such as basil developing more quickly, while others, such as rosemary, require a longer cultivation period.+The app includes a timer to display the remaining time of the current focus session, a display of the current time of day and the phone's battery percentage. The app offers various ways of displaying this to fit the user's taste, all keeping minimalism in check.
  
-Herbs are plants that we use in cooking. They have unique scents and give unique flavor to our dishes. Examples are basil, thyme, oregano, rosemary, cilantro etc. We can grow herbs in both soil and water (hydroponic systems). It's possible to grow them from seed or from cuttings, which are quicker.+=== The Pomodoro Technique ===
  
-With our project, we want to smart farm plants and we're starting with growing herbs because they're one of the easier plants to grow. You start with either a sown seed or a cutting. Sowing seeds means preparing them, you do this by placing them in nutrient-rich environments for germination. This environment needs optimal levels of water, oxygen and temperature. You can sow seeds in either nutrient-rich soil or hydroponic systems. Sowing often happens in smaller environments so you can easily transport the germinated seed to a bigger environment. Tougher seeds, like those of licorice or lemon balm, need a small nick in their seed to allow the nutrients to flow in. This process is called scarification.  
-Secondly there's cuttings. That's where you cut a stem from an herb and put it directly in a growing environment. This makes the plant grow quicker than using the seed since there's already a base. The stem will grow its roots and so the stem transforms into a plant. The stems of this new plant can //also// be cut to repeat the process. You can even use store bought herbs for this. This is very beneficial for hydroponic systems. 
  
-To grow, they need sunlight to activate photosynthesis. With enough light, the plant can create chemicals that stimulate its growth. An herb needs 6 - 8 hours of sunlight every day to grow well [(https://extension.umn.edu/vegetables/growing-herbs)]. Different herbs need different levels of sunlight, basil for example needs much more intense sunlight than bay leaves.  +The Pomodoro Technique is a time management method designed to improve focus and productivity by breaking work into short, structured intervals. 
-Next to sunlight they need proper airflow, good temperature and good humidity levels. Airflow prevents fungal growth which would harm the plant. When it comes to temperature, an herb needs between 18 - 24 degrees Celsius to grow well [(https://extension.umn.edu/vegetables/growing-herbs)]. When it comes to hydroponic systems, you also have to monitor the acidity level of the liquid. An herb can only survive between an environment of 5.5 and 6.5 pH [(https://extension.umn.edu/vegetables/growing-herbs)].+It typically works as follows: 
  
-Most of these aspects stay the same for maintenance, but you also need to account for plant diseases. If any of the prior elements are regulated poorly, the plant can get discolored which means the plant is growing downy mildew or, in case of mint, mint rust. You can save the plant by removing the infected leaves. 
  
-Herbs need between 6 and 8 weeks to grow to harvestable state, though herbs that grew from cuttings need only half of that time [(https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/care/planting/propagation/)]. Some herbs grow more quickly like basil. Herbs like rosemary take more time.+  - Work for 25 minutes (called one “Pomodoro”) 
 +  - Take a 5-minute break 
 +  - After four Pomodoros, take a longer break (15–30 minutes) [(cirillo2006)]
  
-=== Vertical gardening === +This cycle makes it easier for users to focus and maintain concentration for a defined period without feeling overwhelmed.
-Vertical gardening is a way of growing plants upward instead of letting them spread across the ground. Rather than using large horizontal areas, plants are supported on walls, trellises, towers, or stacked containers. This makes it especially useful in cities or small spaces where there isn’t much room for a traditional garden, but people still want to grow plants or food.+
  
-Even though it might seem like a modern idea, vertical gardening has been around for a long time. People have always used supports to grow climbing plants such as beans or grapes. What’s different today is how this idea has developed, especially in urban environments. In recent decades, vertical gardening has become more popular as cities look for greener solutions. A big influence on this trend is Patrick Blanc, who introduced the concept of living walls [(Blanc2026VerticalGarden)]. These are walls covered with plants, often built into buildings, showing that greenery can be added even where there is no ground space. +=== Key Characteristics ===
  
-There are different ways to create a vertical garden. One of the simplest methods is using a trellis, where plants grow upward along a wooden or metal frame. This works well for crops like peas, beans, and cucumbers. More advanced systems include green walls, where plants grow directly on specially designed panels with built-in watering systems. There are also vertical planters, such as stacked pots or hanging containers, and tower gardens, which allow plants to grow in layers and are often used with hydroponics.+  * Timer-based focus sessions that limit phone usage during work periods 
 +  * Gamified rewards, such as points, coins or visual progress 
 +  * Visual representations of productivity, such as growing plants or characters 
 +  * Statistics and tracking systems that allow users to monitor their focus habits
  
-There are several reasons why vertical gardening has become so popular. It saves space, which is important in small homes or apartments. It can also improve air quality, since plants absorb carbon dioxide and release oxygen. On top of that, vertical gardens make spaces look more attractive and can even help cool buildings by providing insulation. Another advantage is that people can grow their own food, like herbs or vegetables, even if they don’t have a traditional garden. 
  
-However, vertical gardening isn’t always easy. Some systems, especially living walls, can be expensive to install. They also need regular maintenance, including watering, pruning, and checking that everything is working properly. The weight of the system can be an issue too, so the structure needs to be strong enough to support it. Choosing the right plants is also important, since not every plant can grow well in vertical conditions or in limited sunlight.+These design strategies rely on behavioural psychology principles, particularly positive reinforcement and goal visualization. The visual representation of progress can make abstract productivity goals more concrete and motivating for users [(locke2002)].
  
-The plants used in vertical gardens are usually lightweight and easy to manage. Herbs like basil, mint, and parsley are common choices, along with leafy greens such as lettuce and spinach. Strawberries are also popular, and climbing plants like beans and peas naturally grow well in vertical systems. For decoration, plants like ferns and ivy are often used because they create a full, green look. [(JainandJanakiram2016VerticalGardening:ANewConceptofModernEra)] 
  
-Overall, vertical gardening is a practical way to grow plants in places where space is limited. It combines older gardening techniques with modern ideas and makes it possible to bring more greenery into urban areas while also supporting small-scale food production. 
  
-=== LED vs natural light for plant growth ===+=== Design ===
  
-In modern plant production, artificial light is no longer treated as simple utility but as a critical nutrient source that can be tailored to drive specific biological responses [(LyineGroup2026)]. While natural sunlight is the traditional baseline, it is often insufficient in intensity and duration, particularly during winter months in northern climates [(Ma2021)][(Paradiso2022)].+Before starting to make a wireframe and user test it, the app developer of the team researched several applications in the field of productivity and mental health. The following apps were researched: Forest, Liven and Minimalist Phone
  
-  
-Sweet basil is widely used in advanced lighting research, where studies show that tuning LED-light to key absorption wavelengths (around 435 nm (blue) and 665 nm (red)) can significantly improve plant growth and yield [(Rihan2020)]. Utilizing a blue wavelength of 435 nm instead of the industry-standard 450 nm can result in a 20 % increase in yield for basil. Furthermore, a ratio of 1.5 blue to 1.0 red has been found optimal for boosting both biomass and the concentration of essential oils [(LyineGroup2026)][(Rihan2020)]. In contrast, generic white LED light can lead to "leggy", structurally weak plants that are unmarketable [(LyineGroup2026)][(PhilipsND)]. 
  
-== Light in relation to DWC, soil, and water growth ==+These apps were researched on their purpose, functionality, design and ease of use. 
 +On the topic of design, all of the researched apps share one thing in common, minimalism. These apps are minimilastic in movement, color choice and design. There are no overwhelming colors or animations and there are no uncomfortable design choices, meaning the layout is simple to understand and the amount of info that's portrayed on the screen is logical. One thing to note is how little the user needs to scroll. Due to the low attention span that's noticeable in today's society, users can't stay on a page that only contains large blocks of text [(simarmata2026attention)]. 
  
-The choice of cultivation system has a direct impact on lightning requirements and overall plant growth.+Firstly, these apps use pages. Forest and Liven have different pages for different purposes, for example a page to see your personal journey and one for your personal profile. Minimalist phone has different pages as well, but this app doesn't show personal progress. Since this app's purpose is to remove all distractions using timers and blocking notifications, it doesn't show any information or progress. The user only sees their timer, battery percentage and the time of day.
  
 +Secondly, these apps use smooth and light animations. By keeping animations locked to their reserved space on the phone, there are no uncomfortable shifts of text or other content which brings the user out of their flow. Using transitions however, the app can show more expressive animations (for example an animation when the user completes a lesson in Liven) that don't hinder the rest of the app's content. This is because the content is shown after the animation is done. Even so, these animations follow the rules of smooth and slow movement in order to keep the user's eyes and brains relaxed [(izraylevych2019animation)].
  
-In DWC specifically, plant roots are submerged in oxygen-rich water, making temperature control essential. For this reason, LED lighting is often preferred, as it produces very little heat and helps prevent the water temperature from rising, which could otherwise lead to root damage or rot. In these systems, roots tend to grow more efficiently because nutrients are readily available, resulting in compact, healthy root structures [(Rihan2020)][(LyineGroup2026)][(Olle2013)].+Thirdly, these apps use low amounts of color to no color at all. Forest and Liven make use of white and green. In the case of dark mode, white gets replaced with a very dark tone of blue. Green calms the mind and keeps the user's eyes relaxed. It is also suggested that the color reduces stress and boosts health [(cherry2025green)]. In the case of Forest, it expresses the feeling of nature and matches with the purpose of the app, being virtue tree growth. 
 +Minimalist phone uses no colors because this app focuses purely on turning the user's phone into a minimalistic screen with only platonically important information. However, the user can set a preset that shows more color.
  
 +In general, using simple colors and animations keeps the user relaxed and takes away stress. By ensuring that the user sees the right information without any distracting information or that which is outside of the current topic, the app avoids any chance of overwhelm.
  
-In contrast, soil-based cultivation leads to a different root development pattern. Roots must spread out in search of nutrients, creating a more extensive but less dense root system [(Ali2023)]. While growing in soil is generally more accessible and requires fewer initial resources, it offers less control over environmental factors such as light intensity. Compared to hydroponic systems, it is therefore more difficult for growers to precisely optimize conditions in soil-based setups [(Signore2020)].+=== Ease of use === 
 +In order to help a user solve their problems, an app needs to be easy to use so the user doesn't lose motivation. To be easy to use, an app needs to have a simple layout, a logical hierarchy of information, a logical focus order, focus on accessibility and fast performance [(rankmyapp2024ux)].
  
 +All the researched apps are simple to use by applying one of two techniques. Firstly, Liven and Forest guide the user throughout the app and its features using text blocks that pop up during app usage. To ensure this doesn't hinder the focus order and user's flow, these text blocks are shown between transitions. Secondly, apps can focus on solely one purpose, removing the need for a user journey. Minimalist phone uses this approach. Instead of having a personalized journey or several goals that the user can achieve, it only shows the current time of day, battery percentage and focus session timer. There are no pages with separate topics, nor are there mutliple topics on pages individually. There is only one page. There are presets of design, but these don't change any of the information shown.
  
-== Reasons to delay LED implementation ==+Minimalist phone's layout is simple, showing only 3 items. Liven and Forest use a completely vertical layout, setting a simple user journey where the user only goes down the screen. This simple layout and the usage of pages for separation of concern enhances the focus order because the user only has 2 ways of navigation, top to bottom and page to page. Because these apps go from top to bottom, it's also accessible for users who use screen readers, for example users with impaired vision. There is no extravagant order of information, meaning the screen reader will always read in the right order. On the topic of accessibility, deaf users have a similar experience because there are no ground-level defining functions using sounds. Liven for example only uses background music that the user can turn on by choice. Sounds don't define the experience, they only enhance it. 
  
-Although LED technology is often described as the future of plant growth, there are several reasons to delay its implementation in the early stages of a project.+There are 2 ways these apps ensure their light weight and fast performance without overloading the phone's processor. Firstly, Forest and minimalist phone have only a handful of features which are very lightweight. Minimalist phone only shows 3 items on the screen and has the option to swap between screen savers. Forest only has features regarding focus sessions and personal profile feedback. Forest also uses animations and art that show the user their virtual forest, but it uses a simple art style and minimal animations. 
 +Secondly, Liven has an abundance of features and more animations than Forest. To counter graphical and computational overload, Liven generates information throughout usage of the app. Since Liven focuses on giving the user a personalized journey, most of the data gets generated at the moment, making the application very lightweight out of the box and throughout usage.
  
 +In general, these apps have several ways of ensuring a simple, fast and reliable user journey for various kinds of users.
  
-First, the initial investment cost is relatively high, as specialized LED systems are significantly more expensive than traditional lighting or simple soil-based setups [(Olle2013)]. Second, the system introduces a level of operational complexity, since optimizing plant growth requires knowledge of Photosynthetic Photon Efficiency (PPE) and Daily Light Integral (DLI) [(LyineGroup2026)]. Incorrect settings can negatively affect plant health, leading to issues such as light stress or poor development.+=== Limitations of Existing Solutions ===
  
  
-In addition, energy efficiency can become a concern if the system is not properly optimized. Using non-specialized or generic LED lighting may increase electricity costs without providing meaningful benefits for plant growth [(LyineGroup2026)].+Despite their popularity, existing focus applications remain entirely digital. The reward mechanisms, such as virtual plants or characters, exist only within the app interface. While these visual systems can motivate users, they may lose effectiveness over time because they do not create a tangible or physical connection to real-world outcomes. 
 +Furthermore, users can often bypass the restrictions of such apps simply by closing the application or ignoring the virtual consequences. As a result, the behavioural impact may be limited in the long term. 
 +This limitation highlights an opportunity for new approaches that connect digital behaviour with real-world feedback. By linking smartphone usage to physical outcomes, such as the growth of a real plant, future systems could create a stronger emotional connection and a more meaningful feedback loop.
  
 +=== Summary ===
  
-Also, natural light intensity is typically much higher in southern countries compared to northern European countries [(Signore2020)]. Because Portugal has a higher DLI year-round, it is not necessary with artificial light as a sole-source for photosynthesis, which is often required in windowless «plant factories» or warehouses in darker climates [(LyineGroup2026)][(Paradiso2022)]. The project will focus on apartments where it is natural to have access to natural lighting. This highlights how geographic location influences the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of LED-based systems.+The current market has several apps that boost the user's motivation, productivity and mental health. These apps share a simple design and fast performance. Another thing they have in common is that they are all designed to be accessible, making the journey as simple as possible for various types of users. Using the color green, some of these apps help boost mental health and keep the user relaxed and calm. Using light and smooth animations, these apps don't overwhelm the user and assist the user in maintaining their focus while keeping the experience fresh and lively. Lastly, these apps have a noticeably flat learning curve due to in-app guidance or due to a small amount of features that are easy to find thanks to their simple layout.
  
  
-Finally, successful use of LED technology often depends on integrating multiple systems, including lighting, climate control, and nutrient delivery. Starting with a simpler grain-based approach allows the project to develop gradually, requiring fewer resources while avoiding unnecessary technical challenges in the early phase [(LyineGroup2026)].+==== Growing Media ====
  
-/*These are examples of citations to books [(Thapa2019)] and [(Obayashi2020)], a chapter on a smart companion [(Reis2020)], articles on IoT [(Hamza2023)], blimps [(Mahn2006)], cloud computing [(Llorente2009)], gas emissions [(Ranjith2020)], pedestrian crossing behaviour [(Sobhani2018)], smart bicycles [(Lee2018)] and diaper moisture [(Khan2018)], and to Web resources [(android41)], [(cloudexpo2008)] and [(gartner2021)]. */+Determining the most efficient method for indoor herb cultivation is necessary to first understand how growth environments affect plant development. In the context of Screen to Green, the medium must act as a responsive bio-indicator of a user’s digital habits while remaining clean and practical for a modern desk environment. 
 + 
 +Traditionally, plants are grown in soil (geoponics), where organic matter acts as a reservoir for water and nutrients. However, soil is often unsuitable for desk-side IoT devices due to its bulk, the potential for mess, and its tendency to harbor pests like fungus gnats [(Barbosa)]. Crucially, soil’s high moisture retention creates a "buffer" that delays visible wilting. For our project, this is a major disadvantage, as we need the plant to show relatively quick visual feedback when a user exceeds their screen time limit.
  
 +An alternative is Hydroponics, specifically Deep Water Culture (DWC). 
 +DWC suspends roots directly in an oxygenated, nutrient-rich water solution. While DWC is very efficient and clean, it can be technically demanding to maintain in a small, portable pot. This led our team to research a "middle ground" known as Semi-Hydroponics
  
 === Hydroponics === === Hydroponics ===
 Hydroponics is a method of growing plants without soil, using water that contains all the necessary nutrients. The roots are supported by materials like clay pellets or coconut fiber, making it ideal for indoor farms, greenhouses, or small urban spaces. Because it doesn’t rely on soil, it allows people to grow plants even where space or ground quality is limited. Hydroponics is a method of growing plants without soil, using water that contains all the necessary nutrients. The roots are supported by materials like clay pellets or coconut fiber, making it ideal for indoor farms, greenhouses, or small urban spaces. Because it doesn’t rely on soil, it allows people to grow plants even where space or ground quality is limited.
  
-The idea has existed for a long time, with early examples like the Aztec Chinampas, where crops were grown on floating platforms. Modern hydroponics was developed in the 20th century and popularized by William Frederick Gericke, who showed that plants could grow using only water and nutrients. [(GrowersNetwork2018TheHistoryofHydroponics)]+The idea has existed for a long time, with early examples like the Aztec Chinampas, where crops were grown on floating platforms. Modern hydroponics was developed in the 20th century and popularized by William Frederick Gericke, who showed that plants could grow using only water and nutrients [(growersnetwork2018)].
  
  
 In hydroponic systems, plants receive nutrients through water, along with oxygen and light. This controlled environment helps plants grow efficiently. It works especially well for herbs because they grow quickly and don’t need large root systems. Common examples include basil, mint, parsley, cilantro, chives, oregano, thyme, and dill, with basil being one of the most popular choices. In hydroponic systems, plants receive nutrients through water, along with oxygen and light. This controlled environment helps plants grow efficiently. It works especially well for herbs because they grow quickly and don’t need large root systems. Common examples include basil, mint, parsley, cilantro, chives, oregano, thyme, and dill, with basil being one of the most popular choices.
  
-Hydroponics has several advantages. Plants often grow faster, use less water due to recycling, and can be grown year-round indoors. There are also fewer pests since no soil is used. However, the system can be expensive to set up, depends on electricity, and requires careful monitoring. If something goes wrong, plants can be affected quickly. [(Rajaseger2023Hydroponics:currenttrendsinsustainablecropproduction)] +Hydroponics has several advantages. Plants often grow faster, use less water due to recycling, and can be grown year-round indoors. There are also fewer pests since no soil is used. However, the system can be expensive to set up, depends on electricity, and requires careful monitoring. If something goes wrong, plants can be affected quickly [(rajaseger2023)]. 
  
 There is also an interesting connection between plants and productivity. Apps like Forest help users stay focused by growing a virtual tree while they avoid distractions. This works because it rewards focus instead of just blocking phone use. Research shows that smartphones are a major source of distraction, with people checking them frequently and losing concentration for long periods. There is also an interesting connection between plants and productivity. Apps like Forest help users stay focused by growing a virtual tree while they avoid distractions. This works because it rewards focus instead of just blocking phone use. Research shows that smartphones are a major source of distraction, with people checking them frequently and losing concentration for long periods.
  
-[(Lee2015Interactionwithindoorplantsmayreducepsychologicalandphysiologicalstress)][(Bringslimark,Hartig,andPatil2009Thepsychologicalbenefitsofindoorplants)] +If this idea is applied to a real plant, the effect could be stronger. A real plant creates a sense of responsibility, which may motivate people more. In addition, having real plants nearby can reduce stress, improve mood, and increase concentration [(lee2015)][(bringslimark2009)].
- +
-If this idea is applied to a real plant, the effect could be stronger. A real plant creates a sense of responsibility, which may motivate people more. In addition, having real plants nearby can reduce stress, improve mood, and increase concentration.+
  
 Overall, combining hydroponics with focus-based systems could help people be more productive while also bringing the benefits of plants into their daily environment. Overall, combining hydroponics with focus-based systems could help people be more productive while also bringing the benefits of plants into their daily environment.
-==== Products ==== 
  
-The increasing use of smartphones has raised concerns about distraction, reduced productivity and digital addiction [(elhai2017)]. In response, many mobile applications have been developed to help users reduce screen time and improve focus. These applications typically rely on behavioural design strategies such as gamification, timers and reward systems to encourage users to stay away from their phones [(duke2017)]. One of the most widely known examples is the mobile application Forest, which has popularized the concept of visualizing focus time through the growth of virtual plants.+==== Semi-Hydroponics ==== 
 +Semi-Hydroponics uses inorganic mineral substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis [(Foliagefactory2024)].  
 +They are specialized growing media made of stones like pumice, zeolites, and volcanic rock, or baked clay granules. Unlike soil, these "grains" are sterile, meaning they don't have worms or attract bugs. They act like a sponge: they soak up the exact amount of water the plant needs and leave plenty of space for air, which prevents root rot.
  
-== Applications ==+The general advantages of these soilless and mineral systems include:
  
 +Controlled Nutrition: Nutrients are delivered directly to the roots in a water-soluble form for faster absorption [(resh2022)].
  
-The application Forest represents one of the most successful examples of this concept. The app was released in 2016 and is available on both mobile platforms and web browsers. Forest encourages users to stay focused by allowing them to plant a virtual tree whenever they start a focus session. The user sets a timer, typically based on the Pomodoro technique and the tree grows while the user avoids using other applications on their phone. If the user leaves the app before the timer ends, the tree withers and dies.+Cleanliness: Removing organic soil eliminates dirt spills and indoor pests, which is a priority for a student's workspace [(Barbosa)].
  
-While applications such as Forest and Flora focus primarily on gamification through virtual plant growth, other tools like Focus To-Do integrate additional productivity features such as task management and progress tracking.+Water Efficiency: These systems use much less water than soil because the moisture is held within the inorganic grains or a small reservoir rather than evaporating into the dirt [(alshrouf2017hydroponics)].
  
-== Key Characteristics ==+Visual Responsiveness: Because these substrates don't have the heavy "water-holding" mass of thick soil, they allow the basil to react more quickly to our automated watering schedule.
  
-  * Timer-based focus sessions that limit phone usage during work periods +While pure DWC is an excellent scientific tool, the use of inorganic substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis offers a slight advantage for Screen to Green. They provide the "grainy" look of soil that users are familiar with, but with the high-tech, clean, and responsive benefits of a hydroponic system and the water reservoir can be smaller than in DWC system.
-  * Gamified rewards, such as points, coins or visual progress +
-  * Visual representations of productivity, such as growing plants or characters +
-  * Statistics and tracking systems that allow users to monitor their focus habits+
  
  
-These design strategies rely on behavioural psychology principles, particularly positive reinforcement and goal visualization. The visual representation of progress can make abstract productivity goals more concrete and motivating for users [(locke2002)]. 
  
 +==== Comparative Growth Analysis: The Case of Basil ====
  
-== Limitations of Existing Solutions ==+To make our Screen to Green project work, we needed to look at how specific plants behave in different environments, and basil turned out to be the perfect choice for our "biological mirror." We found a very important study by Saha et al. [(Saha2016)] that focused exactly on what we are trying to do: comparing common basil grown in traditional soil versus soilless environments. Basil is a great herb for this project because it is very visually-responsive, meaning you can actually see it change based on how much water it has. In the study, the researchers showed that basil in a soilless setup grows much faster and looks much healthier than basil growing in regular dirt. While some systems use only water, our research also points toward "semi-hydroponic" methods using inorganic substrates like Lechuza Pon or Seramis. These are essentially clean, sterile grains that act like a high-tech version of soil without the mess or the bugs. This is really important for our goal of helping people with phone addiction because we want the user to see a "reward" for their hard work. If person is not exceeding their screen time limits or a student is staying focused and studying without their phone, a soilless system allows the basil to grow big and green very quickly. However, because these inorganic substrates and water-based systems don't have the heavy "buffer" of organic dirt, the plant becomes more sensitive to our watering schedule. This is actually a huge benefit for our project; it means that if a user spends too much time scrolling and our system stops the optimal watering, the basil will start to droop and wilt much faster than it would in thick soil. This creates a quick and clear "physical warning" that tells the user to put their phone down and get back to real life. 
 +The following are the key scientific findings based on this research: 
 +  * Faster Growth Height: The researchers found that basil in soilless systems grew taller than the soil-grown plants in the same amount of time. This helps our users see the results of their good study habits almost immediately [(Saha2016)]. 
 +  * More Leaves to See: The study showed that these plants have a much higher leaf count and a bigger total leaf area. This makes the plant look "extra lush," which is the exact visual reward we want to give our users for staying off their phones [(Saha2016)]. 
 +  * Better Root Development: Because the roots in water or loose grains like Seramis don't have to push through hard, compacted dirt, they grow longer and more efficiently. This makes the plant more sensitive to the water levels we control with our system [(Saha2016)]. 
 +  * Lower Water Waste: Even though it seems like it uses a lot of water, soilless methods actually save water compared to soil because the moisture is targeted at the roots and doesn't just evaporate into the dirt [(Saha2016)]. 
 +  * Cleanliness for Apartments: Unlike soil, which was found to be messy and can attract bugs like gnats, using inorganic grains or water stays clean and sterile, which is much better for a student's desk [(Barbosa)].
  
  
-Despite their popularity, existing focus applications remain entirely digital. The reward mechanisms, such as virtual plants or characters, exist only within the app interface. While these visual systems can motivate users, they may lose effectiveness over time because they do not create a tangible or physical connection to real-world outcomes. +=== Growing herbs === 
-Furthermore, users can often bypass the restrictions of such apps simply by closing the application or ignoring the virtual consequences. As a result, the behavioural impact may be limited in the long term. +Herbs are plants commonly used in cooking due to their distinctive aromas and flavors. Examples include basil, thyme, oregano, rosemary, and cilantro. These plants can be cultivated in soil or through hydroponic systems. Propagation is possible either from seeds or from cuttings, with cuttings generally providing faster results.
-This limitation highlights an opportunity for new approaches that connect digital behaviour with real-world feedback. By linking smartphone usage to physical outcomes, such as the growth of a real plant, future systems could create a stronger emotional connection and a more meaningful feedback loop.+
  
 +The cultivation process begins with either sowing seeds or preparing cuttings. Seed sowing involves placing seeds in a nutrient-rich environment suitable for germination. This environment must provide optimal levels of water, oxygen, and temperature. Seeds may be sown in nutrient-rich soil or in hydroponic systems, often within smaller, controlled environments that allow for easy transplantation after germination. Certain seeds, such as those of licorice or lemon balm, require scarification—a process in which the seed coat is slightly nicked to facilitate nutrient absorption.
  
-== The Pomodoro Technique ==+An alternative propagation method involves the use of cuttings. In this approach, a stem is removed from an existing herb plant and placed directly into a growing environment. This method accelerates growth since the cutting already has an established structure. Over time, roots develop, and the stem becomes a fully independent plant. This process can be repeated by taking additional cuttings from the newly grown plant. Even commercially purchased herbs can serve as viable sources for cuttings, making this method particularly advantageous for hydroponic systems.
  
 +Successful growth requires adequate sunlight to enable photosynthesis, allowing the plant to produce compounds necessary for development. Most herbs require approximately 6 to 8 hours of sunlight per day, although light intensity requirements vary between species [(mackenzie2021herbs)]. For example, basil typically requires more intense sunlight than bay leaves. In addition to light, proper airflow, temperature, and humidity levels are essential. Adequate airflow helps prevent fungal growth, while optimal temperatures generally range between 18 °C and 24 °C. In hydroponic systems, maintaining the correct pH level is also critical, with most herbs thriving in a range between 5.5 and 6.5.
  
-The Pomodoro Technique is a time management method designed to improve focus and productivity by breaking work into short, structured intervals. +These environmental factors remain important throughout the maintenance phase. Poor regulation of these conditions can lead to plant diseases, often indicated by discoloration. Common issues include downy mildew and, in the case of mint, mint rust. Infected plants can often be treated by removing affected leaves to prevent further spread.
-It typically works as follows: +
  
 +Under optimal conditions, most herbs reach a harvestable stage within 6 to 8 weeks. However, plants grown from cuttings may require only half that time. Growth rates vary among species, with herbs such as basil developing more quickly, while others, such as rosemary, require a longer cultivation period.
  
-  - Work for 25 minutes (called one “Pomodoro”) 
-  - Take a 5-minute break 
-  - After four Pomodoros, take a longer break (15–30 minutes) [(cirillo2006)] 
  
-This cycle makes it easier for users to focus and maintain concentration for a defined period without feeling overwhelmed.+=== Vertical gardening === 
 +Vertical gardening is a way of growing plants upward instead of letting them spread across the ground. Rather than using large horizontal areas, plants are supported on walls, trellises, towers, or stacked containers. This makes it especially useful in cities or small spaces where there isn’t much room for a traditional garden, but people still want to grow plants or food.
  
 +Even though it might seem like a modern idea, vertical gardening has been around for a long time. People have always used supports to grow climbing plants such as beans or grapes. What’s different today is how this idea has developed, especially in urban environments. In recent decades, vertical gardening has become more popular as cities look for greener solutions. A big influence on this trend is Patrick Blanc, who introduced the concept of living walls [(blanc_verticalgarden)]. These are walls covered with plants, often built into buildings, showing that greenery can be added even where there is no ground space. 
  
-==== Smartphone Usage and Mental Health ====+There are different ways to create a vertical garden. One of the simplest methods is using a trellis, where plants grow upward along a wooden or metal frame. This works well for crops like peas, beans, and cucumbers. More advanced systems include green walls, where plants grow directly on specially designed panels with built-in watering systems. There are also vertical planters, such as stacked pots or hanging containers, and tower gardens, which allow plants to grow in layers and are often used with hydroponics.
  
-The rapid increase in smartphone usage has raised significant concerns regarding its impact on mental health, particularly among young people and students. Numerous studies have found a consistent association between excessive screen time and negative psychological outcomes such as anxiety, depression and stress. +There are several reasons why vertical gardening has become so popular. It saves space, which is important in small homes or apartments. It can also improve air quality, since plants absorb carbon dioxide and release oxygen. On top of that, vertical gardens make spaces look more attractive and can even help cool buildings by providing insulation. Another advantage is that people can grow their own food, like herbs or vegetables, even if they don’t have a traditional garden.
-For example, a study on university students found that as daily screen time increased, levels of anxiety and depression also increased significantly. In particular, screen use above approximately 6.5 hours per day was associated with a higher risk of mental health problems [(zhang2025)]. +
-Several mechanisms help explain the relationship between smartphone use and mental health. One important factor is sleep disruption. Screen exposure, particularly before bedtime, can interfere with sleep quality, which is strongly associated with increased stress and emotional instability.+
  
-Another important aspect is the addictive nature of smartphone use, particularly in relation to social media. Studies have shown that compulsive smartphone use is associated with higher levels of psychological distress, including anxiety and depression [(rozgonjuk2018)]. This is often explained by reward mechanisms in apps, such as notifications and social feedback, which reinforce habitual checking behavior and make it difficult for users to regulate their screen time.+However, vertical gardening isn’t always easy. Some systems, especially living walls, can be expensive to install. They also need regular maintenance, including watering, pruning, and checking that everything is working properly. The weight of the system can be an issue too, so the structure needs to be strong enough to support it. Choosing the right plants is also important, since not every plant can grow well in vertical conditions or in limited sunlight.
  
-Importantly, research also suggests that reducing smartphone usage can lead to measurable improvements in mental health. A randomized controlled trial demonstrated that lowering screen time resulted in improved well-being and reduced psychological distress among participants [(pieh2025)].+The plants used in vertical gardens are usually lightweight and easy to manage. Herbs like basil, mint, and parsley are common choices, along with leafy greens such as lettuce and spinach. Strawberries are also popular, and climbing plants like beans and peas naturally grow well in vertical systems. For decoration, plants like ferns and ivy are often used because they create a full, green look [(jain_janakiram_2016)].
  
-Overall, existing research indicates a clear relationship between excessive smartphone use and negative mental health outcomes. While smartphones offer many benefits, their overuse can contribute to stress, anxiety, depression, and reduced well-being. These findings underline the importance of developing tools and systems that help users manage their screen time more effectively.+Overall, vertical gardening is a practical way to grow plants in places where space is limited. It combines older gardening techniques with modern ideas and makes it possible to bring more greenery into urban areas while also supporting small-scale food production.
  
-==== Similar apps for inspiration ==== +=== LED vs natural light for plant growth ===
-Before starting to make a wireframe and user test it, the app developer of the team researched several applications in the field of productivity and mental health. The following apps were researched. +
-  * [[https://www.forestapp.cc/|Forest]] +
-  * [[https://theliven.com/|Liven]] +
-  * [[https://www.minimalistphone.com/|minimalist phone]] +
-These apps were researched on their purpose, functionality, design and ease of use.+
  
-=== Forest === +In modern plant production, artificial light is no longer treated as simple utility but as a critical nutrient source that can be tailored to drive specific biological responses [(LyineGroup2026)]. While natural sunlight is the traditional baseline, it is often insufficient in intensity and duration, particularly during winter months in northern climates [(Ma2021)][(Paradiso2022)].
-Forest is an app that boosts motivation and productivity using a simulated forest that's maintained by the user. With every productive session, the user grows a virtual tree and when that tree is fully grown, the user starts growing another one. With this, the user is growing a virtual forest, taking care of it by studying, working or being off the phone in general. +
  
-When the user stops the session midway, the current tree dies and the user's forest doesn't grow, countering the user's tendency to open social media during their focus session. Alternatively, when the user enters a focus session, all notifications are blocked, minimizing the user's tendency to get distracted by notifications.+  
 +Sweet basil is widely used in advanced lighting research, where studies show that tuning LED-light to key absorption wavelengths (around 435 nm (blue) and 665 nm (red)) can significantly improve plant growth and yield [(Rihan2020)]. Utilizing a blue wavelength of 435 nm instead of the industry-standard 450 nm can result in a 20 % increase in yield for basil. Furthermore, a ratio of 1.5 blue to 1.0 red has been found optimal for boosting both biomass and the concentration of essential oils [(LyineGroup2026)][(Rihan2020)]. In contrast, generic white LED light can lead to "leggy", structurally weak plants that are unmarketable [(LyineGroup2026)][(PhilipsND)].
  
-=== Liven === +== Light in relation to DWC, soil, and water growth ==
-This app focuses on countering dopamine deficit and procrastination by creating a personal guide with the user during app usage. Liven uses a balance of teaching, self exploration, experience. The user gets taught on dopamine, procrastination and stress-related topics. Inbetween lessons, the app asks the user questions in order to understand the user better, leading to more personalized guidance. While using the app, the user can log their personal thoughts and feelings, which in turn lead to generated affirmation phrases and even more personalized guidance. Lastly, the user receives exercises regarding mental and physical health.+
  
-Liven focuses on personalizing the journey to improve, leading to every user having a unique journey fitting their needs and personality. Using animations that are soft to the eyes, phrases throughout the user's journey for affirmation and the option to personally log thoughts and feelings, Liven allows users to guide themselves to learn about their flaws and how to work with them.  +The choice of cultivation system has a direct impact on lightning requirements and overall plant growth.
-=== minimalist phone === +
-This app minimizes distractions by turning the phone into a screen with a timer and no apps. The user downloads the minimalist phone launcher app in their preferred application store. Using the launcher, the user locks away all forms of distraction including notifications, access to apps and even overwhelming colors such as the user's wallpaper. +
  
-The app includes a timer to display the remaining time of the current focus session, a display of the current time of day and the phone's battery percentage. The app offers various ways of displaying this to fit the user's taste, all keeping minimalism in check. 
-=== Design === 
-On the topic of design, all of the researched apps share one thing in common, minimalism. These apps are minimilastic in movement, color choice and design. There are no overwhelming colors or animations and there are no uncomfortable design choices, meaning the layout is simple to understand and the amount of info that's portrayed on the screen is logical. One thing to note is how little the user needs to scroll. Due to the low attention span that's noticeable in today's society, users can't stay on a page that only contains large blocks of text [(Flicka Miracle Simarmata, 2026. https://sgu.ac.id/the-decline-of-attention-span-in-the-digital-era/ [Accessed in March 2026]. //Swiss German University//)].  
  
-Firstly, these apps use pages. Forest and Liven have different pages for different purposes, for example a page to see your personal journey and one for your personal profile. Minimalist phone has different pages as well, but this app doesn't show personal progress. Since this app's purpose is to remove all distractions using timers and blocking notifications, it doesn't show any information or progress. The user only sees their timer, battery percentage and the time of day.+In DWC specifically, plant roots are submerged in oxygen-rich water, making temperature control essential. For this reason, LED lighting is often preferred, as it produces very little heat and helps prevent the water temperature from rising, which could otherwise lead to root damage or rot. In these systems, roots tend to grow more efficiently because nutrients are readily available, resulting in compact, healthy root structures [(Rihan2020)][(LyineGroup2026)][(Olle2013)].
  
-Secondly, these apps use smooth and light animations. By keeping animations locked to their reserved space on the phone, there are no uncomfortable shifts of text or other content which brings the user out of their flow. Using transitions however, the app can show more expressive animations (for example an animation when the user completes a lesson in Liven) that don't hinder the rest of the app's content. This is because the content is shown after the animation is done. Even so, these animations follow the rules of smooth and slow movement in order to keep the user's eyes and brains relaxed [(Igor Izraylevych, 2019. https://igorizraylevych.medium.com/types-of-animation-for-mobile-apps-d423799f6f0 [Accessed in March 2026]. //Medium//)]. 
  
-Thirdly, these apps use low amounts of color to no color at all. Forest and Liven make use of white and green. In the case of dark mode, white gets replaced with a very dark tone of blue. Green calms the mind and keeps the user's eyes relaxed. It is also suggested that the color reduces stress and boosts health [(Kendra Cherry, 2025. https://www.verywellmind.com/color-psychology-green-2795817 [Accessed in March 2026]. //verywellmind//)]. In the case of Forest, it expresses the feeling of nature and matches with the purpose of the app, being virtue tree growth. +In contrast, soil-based cultivation leads to a different root development pattern. Roots must spread out in search of nutrients, creating a more extensive but less dense root system [(Ali2023)]. While growing in soil is generally more accessible and requires fewer initial resources, it offers less control over environmental factors such as light intensity. Compared to hydroponic systems, it is therefore more difficult for growers to precisely optimize conditions in soil-based setups [(Signore2020)].
-Minimalist phone uses no colors because this app focuses purely on turning the user's phone into a minimalistic screen with only platonically important information. However, the user can set a preset that shows more color.+
  
-In general, using simple colors and animations keeps the user relaxed and takes away stress. By ensuring that the user sees the right information without any distracting information or that which is outside of the current topic, the app avoids any chance of overwhelm. 
  
-=== Ease of use === +== Reasons to delay LED implementation ==
-In order to help a user solve their problems, an app needs to be easy to use so the user doesn't lose motivation. To be easy to use, an app needs to have a simple layout, a logical hierarchy of information, a logical focus order, focus on accessibility and fast performance [(Unknown, 2024. https://rankmyapp.com/en/blog/user-friendly-basic-principles-and-how-to-do-it/ [Accessed in March 2026]. //RankMyApp//)].+
  
-All the researched apps are simple to use by applying one of two techniques. Firstly, Liven and Forest guide the user throughout the app and its features using text blocks that pop up during app usage. To ensure this doesn't hinder the focus order and user's flow, these text blocks are shown between transitions. Secondly, apps can focus on solely one purpose, removing the need for a user journey. Minimalist phone uses this approach. Instead of having a personalized journey or several goals that the user can achieve, it only shows the current time of day, battery percentage and focus session timer. There are no pages with separate topics, nor are there mutliple topics on pages individually. There is only one page. There are presets of design, but these don't change any of the information shown.+Although LED technology is often described as the future of plant growth, there are several reasons to delay its implementation in the early stages of a project.
  
-Minimalist phone's layout is simple, showing only 3 items. Liven and Forest use a completely vertical layout, setting a simple user journey where the user only goes down the screen. This simple layout and the usage of pages for separation of concern enhances the focus order because the user only has 2 ways of navigation, top to bottom and page to page. Because these apps go from top to bottom, it's also accessible for users who use screen readers, for example users with impaired vision. There is no extravagant order of information, meaning the screen reader will always read in the right order. On the topic of accessibility, deaf users have a similar experience because there are no ground-level defining functions using sounds. Liven for example only uses background music that the user can turn on by choice. Sounds don't define the experience, they only enhance it.  
  
-There are 2 ways these apps ensure their light weight and fast performance without overloading the phone's processor. Firstly, Forest and minimalist phone have only a handful of features which are very lightweight. Minimalist phone only shows 3 items on the screen and has the option to swap between screen savers. Forest only has features regarding focus sessions and personal profile feedback. Forest also uses animations and art that show the user their virtual forest, but it uses a simple art style and minimal animations. +First, the initial investment cost is relatively high, as specialized LED systems are significantly more expensive than traditional lighting or simple soil-based setups [(Olle2013)]. Second, the system introduces a level of operational complexity, since optimizing plant growth requires knowledge of Photosynthetic Photon Efficiency (PPE) and Daily Light Integral (DLI) [(LyineGroup2026)]. Incorrect settings can negatively affect plant health, leading to issues such as light stress or poor development.
-Secondly, Liven has an abundance of features and more animations than Forest. To counter graphical and computational overload, Liven generates information throughout usage of the app. Since Liven focuses on giving the user a personalized journey, most of the data gets generated at the moment, making the application very lightweight out of the box and throughout usage.+
  
-In general, these apps have several ways of ensuring a simple, fast and reliable user journey for various kinds of users. 
  
-=== Summary ===+In addition, energy efficiency can become a concern if the system is not properly optimized. Using non-specialized or generic LED lighting may increase electricity costs without providing meaningful benefits for plant growth [(LyineGroup2026)].
  
-The current market has several apps that boost the user's motivation, productivity and mental health. These apps share a simple design and fast performance. Another thing they have in common is that they are all designed to be accessible, making the journey as simple as possible for various types of users. Using the color green, some of these apps help boost mental health and keep the user relaxed and calm. Using light and smooth animations, these apps don't overwhelm the user and assist the user in maintaining their focus while keeping the experience fresh and lively. Lastly, these apps have a noticeably flat learning curve due to in-app guidance or due to a small amount of features that are easy to find thanks to their simple layout. + 
-==== Aerogarden harvest  ====+Also, natural light intensity is typically much higher in southern countries compared to northern European countries [(Signore2020)]. Because Portugal has a higher DLI year-round, it is not necessary with artificial light as a sole-source for photosynthesis, which is often required in windowless «plant factories» or warehouses in darker climates [(LyineGroup2026)][(Paradiso2022)]. The project will focus on apartments where it is natural to have access to natural lighting. This highlights how geographic location influences the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of LED-based systems. 
 + 
 + 
 +Finally, successful use of LED technology often depends on integrating multiple systems, including lighting, climate control, and nutrient delivery. Starting with a simpler grain-based approach allows the project to develop gradually, requiring fewer resources while avoiding unnecessary technical challenges in the early phase [(LyineGroup2026)]. 
 + 
 +/*These are examples of citations to books [(Thapa2019)] and [(Obayashi2020)], a chapter on a smart companion [(Reis2020)], articles on IoT [(Hamza2023)], blimps [(Mahn2006)], cloud computing [(Llorente2009)], gas emissions [(Ranjith2020)], pedestrian crossing behaviour [(Sobhani2018)], smart bicycles [(Lee2018)] and diaper moisture [(Khan2018)], and to Web resources [(android41)], [(cloudexpo2008)] and [(gartner2021)]. */ 
 + 
 + 
 + 
 +==== Products  ==== 
 + 
 +=== Aerogarden harvest ===
  
  
Line 248: Line 240:
  
  
-=== Advantages and limitations ===+== Advantages and limitations ==
  
  
Line 255: Line 247:
 Hydroponic systems also use space and resources efficiently. Research shows that soilless systems can support high plant density while using less water and fewer resources through recirculating nutrient systems [(Rajput2025)]. Hydroponic systems also use space and resources efficiently. Research shows that soilless systems can support high plant density while using less water and fewer resources through recirculating nutrient systems [(Rajput2025)].
  
-However, the system has clear limitations. Users must still manually refill water and add nutrients [(AmazonND)] [(Virginia2024)]. More importantly, the system focuses only on plant growth and does not influence user behavior. It does not connect plant care to user habits or provide meaningful behavioral feedback.+However, the system has clear limitations. Users must still manually refill water and add nutrients [(AmazonND)][(Virginia2024)]. More importantly, the system focuses only on plant growth and does not influence user behavior. It does not connect plant care to user habits or provide meaningful behavioral feedback.
  
  
-=== Gaps and opportunities ===+== Gaps and opportunities ==
  
  
Line 272: Line 264:
  
 In these systems, the data collected by sensors is sent to a central system or a mobile application. Based on this data, the system can either provide feedback to the user or react automatically. For example, irrigation systems can be activated when soil moisture drops below a certain level, and lighting can be adjusted depending on environmental conditions. Studies on small-scale hydroponic systems show that this type of monitoring and control can also be applied effectively in home environments [(abdul2025)]. Because of this, people do not need to check their plants all the time, and the growing conditions can remain more stable. Some studies suggest that maintaining controlled conditions can improve consistency in plant growth and resource use, although the results still depend on system design and maintenance [(kebai2018)]. In these systems, the data collected by sensors is sent to a central system or a mobile application. Based on this data, the system can either provide feedback to the user or react automatically. For example, irrigation systems can be activated when soil moisture drops below a certain level, and lighting can be adjusted depending on environmental conditions. Studies on small-scale hydroponic systems show that this type of monitoring and control can also be applied effectively in home environments [(abdul2025)]. Because of this, people do not need to check their plants all the time, and the growing conditions can remain more stable. Some studies suggest that maintaining controlled conditions can improve consistency in plant growth and resource use, although the results still depend on system design and maintenance [(kebai2018)].
- 
  
 === Key Technologies === === Key Technologies ===
Line 280: Line 271:
 One of the most important parts of home smart farming is the Internet of Things (IoT). It basically allows different devices to connect and share data with each other. In this kind of system, sensors like soil moisture sensors, temperature sensors, and light sensors are used to keep checking the environment around the plant. One of the most important parts of home smart farming is the Internet of Things (IoT). It basically allows different devices to connect and share data with each other. In this kind of system, sensors like soil moisture sensors, temperature sensors, and light sensors are used to keep checking the environment around the plant.
 The data collected from these sensors is usually sent to a central system or a mobile application. This makes it possible for users to check the condition of their plants in real time and control the system even when they are not at home. According to recent research, IoT helps improve how accurately these conditions are monitored and supports better decision-making by providing continuous data [(sheikh2025)]. It has also been used in small hydroponic systems to monitor things like pH, temperature, and water quality, which shows that it can work well even at a home scale [(abdul2025)]. The data collected from these sensors is usually sent to a central system or a mobile application. This makes it possible for users to check the condition of their plants in real time and control the system even when they are not at home. According to recent research, IoT helps improve how accurately these conditions are monitored and supports better decision-making by providing continuous data [(sheikh2025)]. It has also been used in small hydroponic systems to monitor things like pH, temperature, and water quality, which shows that it can work well even at a home scale [(abdul2025)].
- 
  
 == Automation Systems == == Automation Systems ==
Line 318: Line 308:
 Finally, even though the system is automated, it still needs regular maintenance. Things like pumps, irrigation lines, and nutrient systems have to be checked and cleaned. Research shows that issues such as clogging or biofilm formation can reduce system efficiency if they are not properly managed [(tahir2026)]. Finally, even though the system is automated, it still needs regular maintenance. Things like pumps, irrigation lines, and nutrient systems have to be checked and cleaned. Research shows that issues such as clogging or biofilm formation can reduce system efficiency if they are not properly managed [(tahir2026)].
  
-==== Projects ==== 
-//Search, select and describe related research projects// 
  
 ==== Comparative Analysis ==== ==== Comparative Analysis ====
Line 329: Line 317:
 <caption>Table comparing different products on the market</caption> <caption>Table comparing different products on the market</caption>
 |**Photo**|**Product**|**Purpose**|**Automation level**|**Space**|**Sensors & technology**|**User effort**|**Price**|**Key limitation**| |**Photo**|**Product**|**Purpose**|**Automation level**|**Space**|**Sensors & technology**|**User effort**|**Price**|**Key limitation**|
-|{{ :report:aerogarden_amazon_pic.png?200 |}} |AeroGarden Harvest|Indoor hydroponic plant growth|Semi-automated (light + reminders|Medium|LED lights, water system, basic alerts|Medium|99.95 $|Expensive over time (pods)| +|{{ :report:aerogarden_amazon_pic.png?200 |}} |AeroGarden Harvest [(AeroGardenND)]|Indoor hydroponic plant growth|Semi-automated (light + reminders|Medium|LED lights, water system, basic alerts|Medium|99.95 $|Expensive over time (pods)| 
-|{{ :report:smart_gardening.png?200 |}} |Smart farming systems|Efficient agriculture or home food production|High (sensors + automation)|Medium - Large|IoT sensors, automated irrigation|Low - medium|69.90 $ ++|Relies heavily on Wi-Fi, basic monitoring for being "smart"| +|{{ :report:smart_gardening.png?200 |}} |Smart farming systems [(SmartWateringND)]|Efficient agriculture or home food production|High (sensors + automation)|Medium - Large|IoT sensors, automated irrigation|Low - medium|69.90 $ ++|Relies heavily on Wi-Fi, basic monitoring for being "smart"| 
-| {{ :report:regular_plantpot.png?200 |}}|Traditional plant pot|Manual plant care|None|Small|None|High|21.99 $ (5-pack)|Requires constant user attention|+| {{ :report:regular_plantpot.png?200 |}}|Traditional plant pot [(PlantPotND)]|Manual plant care|None|Small|None|High|21.99 $ (5-pack)|Requires constant user attention|
 </table> </table>
  
Line 341: Line 329:
 <caption>Table showing different applications/systems already on the market</caption> <caption>Table showing different applications/systems already on the market</caption>
 |**Application**|**Feedback type**|**Strength**| |**Application**|**Feedback type**|**Strength**|
-|Forest|Visual (virtual trees)|Highly engaging| +|Forest [(ForestAppND)]|Visual (virtual trees)|Highly engaging| 
-|Flora|Visual + social|Social motivation| +|Flora [(FloraAppND)]|Visual + social|Social motivation| 
-|Focus To-Do|Data/statistics|Productivity features|+|Focus To-Do [(FocusToDoND)]|Data/statistics|Productivity features|
 |Screen time (built-in)|Data only|Easy access| |Screen time (built-in)|Data only|Easy access|
 </table> </table>
Line 349: Line 337:
  
 ==== Summary ==== ==== Summary ====
-//Provide here the conclusions of this chapter and make the bridge to the next chapter.// +This chapter showed that while digital solutions can help reduce screen time, their impact is limited by their virtual nature. 
- +At the same time, physical systems enable plant growth but do not influence user behavior. 
- +This highlights a gap between digital behavior tracking and physical feedback systems and demonstrates the need for the Screen2Green project by linking smartphone usage to a real-world element. 
- +These findings provide the foundation for the next chapter, which outlines the project management and development process.
- +
  
-Based on this study of the state of the art, the team decided to adopt the following <specify here the architecture, technique(s), material(s), component(s)> because <specify here the technical/scientific reasons>.  
  • report/soa.1775989130.txt.gz
  • Last modified: 2026/04/12 11:18
  • by team1